John Smith at St Pancras Old Church: A Beautiful Hour of Escapism
St Pancras Old Church, London | 19 November 2026
UTS Rating: (5/5)
Since I first started going to End of the Road Festival in 2013, I’ve attended 13 times and discovered countless wonderful bands and artists along the way. Some provide a memorable hour or two before disappearing into the festival memory bank. Others stay with you. You buy their albums, follow their careers and make a point of seeing them whenever you can. John Smith is one of those artists, and one of my very favourites.
I first discovered him at End of the Road some years ago and have since sought him out at Cecil Sharp House, Union Chapel and the Barbican, where he supported Suzanne Vega in 2022. Now I can add the beautiful St Pancras Old Church to that collection, where Smith is enjoying a week-long residency, with each evening devoted to a different album or musical theme. Thursday night’s offering was his wonderful 2017 album Headlong, performed in its entirety.
I’d visited this little church once before, many years ago, and had almost forgotten quite how lovely it is. Tucked away close to the bustle of King’s Cross, it provides an intimate and atmospheric setting for live music, particularly music as gentle and beautifully crafted as Smith’s. For an hour or so, the outside world simply ceased to exist.
The history of the church is almost as remarkable as the setting itself. Believed to occupy one of London’s oldest sites of Christian worship, it retains elements of its medieval origins, despite extensive restoration during the Victorian era. Mary Wollstonecraft married William Godwin here in 1797 and was originally buried in the churchyard, while The Beatles famously visited the grounds for photographs during their 1968 ‘Mad Day Out’. Since 2011, the church has also established itself as one of London’s most atmospheric intimate music venues. There’s something rather wonderful about a building with so many centuries of history continuing to provide a home for contemporary musicians.
There’s something wonderfully unassuming about John Smith. Even his name sounds almost determinedly ordinary, and his manner is similarly understated. No airs, no graces, no unnecessary fuss. Just a man with a guitar, a beautiful voice, a dry sense of humour and an extraordinary amount of talent.
And what talent it is.
Smith’s guitar playing is, quite simply, exquisite. His intricate fingerpicking creates such a rich, layered sound that at times it’s difficult to believe there’s only one guitar on stage. Melody, rhythm and bass seem to weave independently around one another, all produced by two astonishingly skilled hands. Yet there’s nothing remotely showy about it. He makes the technically remarkable appear completely effortless, never allowing his virtuosity to overshadow the songs themselves. I’ve only ever seen Smith perform solo without a band, and I honestly cannot imagine needing anything more.
You could have heard a pin drop in that church. The audience was utterly captivated, and what an absolute pleasure it was to be surrounded by people who had come simply to listen. No phones held aloft, no distracting chatter, just a room full of people completely absorbed in the music. It reminded me of one of the things I love most about End of the Road, where the music really does come first. There was an almost spiritual quality to the experience, something approaching a religious one, despite this being a concert rather than a church service. In those beautiful surroundings, with Smith’s extraordinary guitar playing filling the space and everyone listening so intently, it was difficult not to feel something rather special.
As promised, the evening followed the track listing of Headlong, opening with Living in Disgrace before moving swiftly into two of my personal favourites, the title track and Far Too Good. Smith joked about getting the big hitters out of the way early in the evening, a consequence of playing the album in its original order. But what a treat to hear those songs so close together. Both are glorious examples of his songwriting, combining beautiful melodies with that unmistakable guitar work.
Between songs, Smith chatted easily about his life as a working musician. He spoke about the financial uncertainties of making a living from music, his years playing sessions and his experiences touring America with David Gray. There was nothing self-important about these stories, just an engaging honesty about the realities of a career that, however romantic it might look from the audience, hasn’t always been straightforward.
Not that Smith was entirely reverential about his surroundings. He joked about swearing in church and entertained us with a story about taking magic mushrooms and writing songs. It was all delivered with that same wonderfully dry, self-deprecating humour, providing a little light relief amid the more reflective moments. The contrast between the sacred surroundings and his decidedly earthly anecdotes only added to the evening’s charm.
And perhaps that’s part of what makes him so appealing. His music is rooted in real life, with all its complications, frustrations, joys and small triumphs. He talks warmly about his wife and family, and there’s a genuine sense of contentment in much of his songwriting, but never the suggestion that happiness has necessarily come easily.
For me, the emotional highlight was Save My Life, which closes the album and has long been one of my favourite John Smith songs. It’s an extraordinarily romantic piece of songwriting, full of love, gratitude and the sense of finding something precious in another person. It’s one of those songs that makes me think about the people I’ve loved, and perhaps one person in particular. Music has a wonderful way of doing that, taking somebody else’s very personal words and making them feel as though they belong to your own story. And that’s exactly what Save My Life does for me. It’s a song I can lose myself in completely, and hearing it performed live in such beautiful surroundings was genuinely moving.
The evening also featured Fiona Bevan, another hugely talented singer-songwriter whom I’ve enjoyed seeing perform on several previous occasions. Unfortunately, I arrived too late to catch her support set, but it was lovely to see her join Smith on stage for a song towards the end of the evening. Their voices complemented one another beautifully, adding a further touch of warmth to an already special night.
There are musicians who command attention through spectacle, and others who achieve something far more difficult: making an audience forget that they’re watching a performance at all. Smith belongs firmly in the latter category. His songs feel natural and effortless, his stories are engaging without being rehearsed to death, and his musicianship is exceptional without ever demanding applause for its own sake.
Perhaps that’s why I’ve continued to seek him out since that first encounter at End of the Road. There is something deeply reassuring about his music, something honest, comforting and very human.
Walking back out into the November night, I felt genuinely grateful for that hour spent in his company. No grand production, no theatrics, just beautiful songs, an extraordinary guitar player and a little space to forget about everything else.
John Smith is quite simply good for the soul.
