There are some shows that defy description. Attempting to explain Otto & Astrid to someone who hasn’t seen them would probably result in a few raised eyebrows. A fictional German electro-punk sibling duo, childhood trauma involving a lion, original songs and increasingly absurd storytelling sounds like complete chaos on paper. On stage, however, it becomes one of the funniest and most joyously original evenings I’ve spent in a theatre.
Fresh from acclaimed runs in New York, Los Angeles and San Francisco, Otto & Astrid: The Stages Tour arrived at Soho Theatre last night for its final two London stops before heading to the Edinburgh Fringe. It proved the perfect setting for a show that feels equally at home in an intimate cabaret space and on a much larger stage.
Like Spinal Tap before them, Otto & Astrid never wink at the audience. Every bizarre anecdote, every sibling argument and every outlandish revelation is delivered with complete sincerity. Otto’s recurring references to the childhood trauma of his parents being eaten by a lion are so earnestly recounted that you somehow find yourself laughing while simultaneously feeling sorry for him. Lesser performers might chase the laughs. Clare Bartholomew and Daniel Tobias trust their characters completely, and that’s exactly why the comedy lands.
The comparisons with Spinal Tap extend beyond the deadpan delivery. The music itself is genuinely excellent. These aren’t throwaway comedy songs. They’re witty, inventive, surprisingly catchy and performed by two exceptionally accomplished musicians. Switching effortlessly between guitar, synths, percussion and keytar, the pair demonstrate that beneath the absurd personas lies serious musical talent. There are affectionate nods to synth-pop acts such as Pet Shop Boys, Depeche Mode and Tom Tom Club, alongside flashes of punk attitude, but the duo never feel like an imitation. Instead, they lovingly send up those influences while creating something entirely their own.
Numbers including Kitten, Second Best Friend and Tasty Snack prove that the songwriting is every bit as clever as the comedy. During Kitten, Otto dons a cute pair of cat ears, one of many gloriously daft visual touches that perfectly complements the duo’s offbeat humour. Long after the final bow, it’s the songs, as much as the jokes, that linger in the memory.
While both performers are outstanding, Daniel Tobias’s Otto completely stole my heart. Beneath the swaggering rock-star persona lies an unexpectedly vulnerable character. It’s not that his “unauthorised” songs reveal a softer musical side. If anything, they’re some of his boldest moments, complete with synth-heavy arrangements and Depeche Mode-style lighting that Otto enthusiastically requests himself. Rather, it’s the act of sneaking them into the set behind Astrid’s back that reveals his vulnerability. Like an excited child trying to get away with something before being caught, Otto’s eagerness and quiet determination make him impossible not to root for and this audience was absolutely on board.
Otto’s antics, however, only work because Clare Bartholomew’s Astrid is such a magnificent foil. Commanding the stage with delicious authority, she combines theatrical flair, impeccable comic timing and an almost maternal determination to keep Otto firmly in line. Their dysfunctional sibling relationship feels utterly authentic, every interruption, glare and squabble suggesting decades of shared history. Their chemistry is exceptional, and together they create characters who feel astonishingly real within their wonderfully warped universe.
Audience interaction is woven naturally throughout, drawing everyone further into Otto and Astrid’s peculiar world without ever feeling forced. The packed Soho ‘downstairs’ quickly surrendered to the madness, happily embracing every bizarre story and increasingly ridiculous revelation.
It’s easy to dismiss comedy music acts as novelty performances, but Otto & Astrid are something much richer. Their meticulous character work, razor-sharp writing and genuinely impressive musicianship combine to create an evening that’s as accomplished as it is hilarious.
Somewhere between the deadpan humour, brilliantly crafted songs, tales of lions and Otto completely stealing my heart, Otto & Astrid gave me one of the most joyously uplifting evenings I’ve had in a long time and I smiled all the way to the tube.
Next stop: Edinburgh! Otto & Astrid: The Stages Tour runs at Assembly Roxy during the Edinburgh Festival Fringe from 5 to 30 August 2026. If you’re heading to the Fringe this summer, I’d strongly recommend adding them to your list.
UTS Rating: đđđđ






